Author(s): <Dana Shum>
Description of Problem
The way that Resource Citation appears in UMM, MMT, and CMR needs to be improved.
Definition of 'Resource Citation': the text that someone using the collection data in research should use to cite the collection in professional scientific literature.
DAACs are using Citations according to different formats, and these are at the discretion of the DAAC manager. ESDIS provides guidance for Citations, and the MMT form needs to have some logic to enable these Citations to be formatted correctly. The addition of a Preview button could be added to the MMT form, which shows how the Citation would look, or the card for Citation needs to be revised. Title and Name are not required in the MMT form since these relate to the Collection by default, and logic needs to be introduced to make DOI and RelatedURL either-or.
See https://earthdata.nasa.gov/earth-observation-data/data-citations-acknowledgements for individual DAAC citation rules.
The UMM needs to be revised to ensure that any unnecessary fields have been removed. For each collection, the EDSC needs to display the citation, per NASA guidelines, and using the formats provided by each DAAC.
Issues:
a. The ResourceCitation/Title is the Title of the Collection. This information should not be collected or stored separately from the Entry Title of the Collection.
b. The ResourceCitation/Publisher is the Data Center which publishes the collection. This information should not be collected or stored separately from the Data Center information.
- should we use Data Center ShortName or Long Name?
- which Data Center role maps here ? (Archiver, Distributor, Originator, Processor)
JIRA Linkage
ECSE-87 - Getting issue details... STATUS
<Ctrl+Shift+J allows you to link to your ECSE JIRA ticket easily. Replace the ticket above with your ticket>
The sections below detail the proposed changes based on the analysis done by the ECSE team:
Affected issues include:
Issues which require the Citation relation to be better defined:
MMT-543 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-392 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-433 - Getting issue details... STATUS
MMT-438 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-344 - Getting issue details... STATUS
Issues which related to Citation format on a DAAC-by-DAAC basis
UMMC-153 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-193 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-153 - Getting issue details... STATUS
Issues pertaining to DOI or RelatedURL fields to be used
ECSE-76 - Getting issue details... STATUS
Issues pertaining to UMM Citation improvements
UMMC-142 - Getting issue details... STATUS
UMMC-145 - Getting issue details... STATUS
Recommendation 1: Modify MMT per the recommended changes below. Provide a recommended format example for each DAAC, and invite the DAACs which have not yet particpated in the Beta testing for the MMT form to provide an example ResourceCitation format. Collect these in this wiki page to provide a defined format. Review these against the NASA guidelines included in this page. Update the MMT form to show a preview of the format following saved changes, either in a text string format showing the actual formatted citation, prior to publication of the record. Remove any fields which pertain to PublicationReference (subject to separate JIRA ticket).
Changes to UMM-C fields
UMMC-344 - Getting issue details... STATUS
ECSE-76 - Getting issue details... STATUS
ECSE-65 - Getting issue details... STATUS
ResourceCitation
Currently: Change to:
| ResourceCitation | |
|---|---|
| ResourceCitation | |
| ResourceCitation/Creators | ResourceCitation/Creators |
| ResourceCitation/Editors | |
| ResourceCitation/Title | ResourceCitation/Title |
| ResourceCitation/SeriesName | ResourceCitation/SeriesName |
| ResourceCitation/ReleaseDate | ResourceCitation/ReleaseDate |
| ResourceCitation/ReleasePlace | ResourceCitation/ReleasePlace |
| ResourceCitation/Publisher | |
| ResourceCitation/Version | ResourceCitation/Version |
| ResourceCitation/IssueIdentification | |
| ResourceCitation/DataPresentation | |
| ResourceCitation/OtherCitationDetails | |
| ResourceCitation/DOI | ResourceCitation/DOI |
| ResourceCitation/DOI/Authority | ResourceCitation/DOI/Authority |
| ResourceCitation/DOI/DOI | ResourceCitation/DOI/DOI |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/URLContentType | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Type | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Subtype | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Protocol | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Title | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Description | ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Description |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Caption | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/URL | ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/URL |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/MimeType | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/FileSize | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Size | |
| ResourceCitation/RelatedURL/Unit |
Changes to UMM-Common fields
ECSE-135 - Getting issue details... STATUS
Mappings to DIF, ECHO, ISO
See mapping between DIF9, DIF10, ECHO10 and UMM-C (suggested) below:
| DIF9 | DIF10 | UMM-C | ECHO10 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elements | Req | C | Elements | Req | C | Elements | Req | C | Elements | Req | C |
| Data_Set_Citation | N | 0..* | Dataset_Citation | N | 0..* | Resource Citation | N | 0..* | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Creator | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Creator | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/Creators | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Editor | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Editor | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/Editors | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Title | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Title | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/Title | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Series_Name | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Series_Name | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/SeriesName | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Release_Date | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Release_Date | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/ReleaseDate | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Release_Place | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Release_Place | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/ReleasePlace | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_Publisher | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Dataset_Publisher | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/Publisher | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Version | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Version | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/Version | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Issue_Identification | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Issue_Identification | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/IssueIdentification | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Data_Presentation_Form | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Data_Presentation_Form | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/DataPresentationForm | N | 0..1 | |||
| Data_Set_Citation/Other_Citation_Details | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Other_Citation_Details | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/OtherCitationDetails | N | 0..1 | CitationForExternalPublication | N | 0..1 |
| Data_Set_Citation/Dataset_DOI | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Persistent_Identifier | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/DOI | N | 0..1 | |||
| Dataset_Citation/Persistent_Identifier/Type (DOI or ARK) | Y | 1 | DOI only | N/A | N/A | ||||||
| ResourceCitation/DOI/Authority | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| Dataset_Citation/Persistent_Identifier/Identifier | Y | 1 | ResourceCitation/DOI/DOI | Y | 1 | ||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/ContentType ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/Relation | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/ContentType/Type | Y | 1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/ContentType/Subtype | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/Protocol | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/Title | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/Description | N | 0..1 | |||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/Caption | 0..1 | ||||||||||
| Data_Set_Citation/Online_Resource | N | 0..1 | Dataset_Citation/Online_Resource | N | 0..1 | ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/URL | Y | 1..* | |||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/MimeType | 0..1 | ||||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/FileSize | 0..1 | ||||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/FileSize/Size | 1 | ||||||||||
| ResourceCitation/RelatedUrl/FileSize/Unit | 1 |
Interoperability Considerations
We have NASA guidelines on how to Cite and Acknowledge EOSDIS Data and Other Items.
Examples of data citations are given as:
- Sankaran M., N. P. Hanan, and R. J. Scholes. 2007. Characteristics of African Savanna Biomes for Determining Woody Cover. Data set. Available on-line [http://www.daac.ornl.gov] from NASA EOSDIS Oak Ridge National Laboratory DAAC, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, U.S.A. doi:10.3334/ORNLDAAC/850, Accessed May 11, 2012.
- Njoku, Eni. 2004, updated daily. AMSR-E/Aqua L2B Surface Soil Moisture, Ancillary Parms, & QC EASE-Grids V002, March to June 2004. NASA EOSDIS National Snow and Ice Data Center DAAC, Boulder, Colorado USA. http://dx.doi.org/10.7265/N5, Accessed July 18, 2013.
- Oak Ridge National Laboratory Distributed Active Archive Center (ORNL DAAC). 2014. MODIS subsetted land products, Collection 5. Available on-line [http://daac.ornl.gov/MODIS/modis.html] from NASA EOSDIS ORNL DAAC, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, U.S.A. Accessed July 24, 2014. Subset obtained for MOD13Q1 product at 35.9587N,84.2874W, time period: 2000-02-18 to 2000-04-06, and subset size: 0.25 x 0.25 km.
Note that there are specific differences between the fields in the examples and the ISO CI_Citation class fields. For example, edition, editionDate, identifier, citedResponsibeParty, presentationForm, series, otherCitationDetails ISBN, ISSN, and graphic are not in the NASA recommended format. Other fields are present in the NASA recommended format, but not in the ISO CI_Citation class: doi or RelatedURL, and note CI_OnlineResource is not needed as a class, RelatedURL can suffice.
CI_Citation is shown in the Figure below.
Figure 1. ISO 19115-1 CI_Citation class representation.
Changes to CMR
CMR-2414 - Getting issue details... STATUS
What should the MMT forms look like
Recommendation:
- Remove Collection Citation form altogether
- Add Collection Landing page and/or Collection DOI Landing page to Collection information form
- Depend upon DAACs to follow NASA guidance (see paper below) and put the following three things on the Collection Landing page and/or Collection DOI Landing page:
- suggested citation,
- pointer to formatting site, and
- link to Data Citations and Acknowledgements on Data Center home page
MMT-543 - Getting issue details... STATUS
MMT-438 - Getting issue details... STATUS
MMT-384 - Getting issue details... STATUS
MMT-421 - Getting issue details... STATUS
MMT-437 - Getting issue details... STATUS
ResourceCitation
>Remove the Title
>Remove the Name
>Move DOI to the Collection Information section of the MMT
>Make DOI and RelatedURL either/or
How should the values in these fields be presented to the user on the EDSC
<Describe changes to EDSC in terms of facet changes, data display changes or functionality changes>
EDSC-441 - Getting issue details... STATUS
The DAAC specific format for the ResourceCitation should appear on the EDSC in relation to the Collection.
Recommendation is to display the fully constructed Resource Citation for the collection when the user is retrieving collection data (i.e., on the Data Access page), with an introductory sentence explaining that if data from this collection is used in research, the collection must be cited in research papers as shown in the fully constructed Resource Citation.
NSIDC example :
Alley, R. and J. Fegyveresi. 2014. NSIDC Test Data Set, Version 1. [Indicate subset used]. Boulder, Colorado USA. NSIDC: National Snow and Ice Data Center. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.7265/N5JW8BTJ. [Date Accessed].
ORNL example:
"Chini, L.P., G.C. Hurtt, and S. Frolking, 2014, Harmonized Global Land Use for Years 1500-2100, V1. Data Set. Available on-line http://daac.ornl.gov from Oak Ridge National Laboratory Distributed Active Archive Center, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, USA. http://dx.doi.org/10.3334/ORNLDAAC/1248"
How should pick lists / controlled vocabulary be handled?
| Resource Citation Field | Current Source of Pick list values (MMT) | Proposed Source of Pick list values | Is this field used for EDSC Faceted Search? |
|---|---|---|---|
Reconciliation of Existing Metadata values with new rules
Impact of Changes on Ingest of Granule Metadata
Overview
Content Tools