Date
Attendees:
ASDC - Tiffany Trapasso
NSIDC - Donna Scott, Steve Tanner
ASF - Rebecca Miller, Olena Ellis (add to list - main point of access)
OB - Alicia Scott
GES DISC - Lena Iredell, Carlee Loeser
LP - Carolyn Gaecke, Jackie Jones
CDDIS - Sandara Blevins (forwarded by Pat Michael) - Add to list
ESDIS - Valerie, Lalit, Elli
PODAAC - Jessica
ORNL- Tammy, Daine on at 1:25
LAADS - Asad
Agenda
- Welcome - Roundtable Introductions
- Since we met last…
- DOI discussion with ORNL
- DOI discussion w GES
- DOI discussion w CMR
- DOI System Update - Lalit
- Overall system Fine
- DAACs are getting Reservations and Deletes are happening - good clean-up effort
- ASDC models bulk update-mechanism - worked well
- Comments
- NSIDC - DataCite has a mechanism for “Graveyard” probably similar to DataCite “reserve” mechanism - Lalit will follow-up)
- Steve has a data product that won’t be public but created years ago - follow-up on that
- DOIs Discussion Page
- https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yr9UdTYGIEqkNLjjJBxYNnGkpTTGEoNtp2DjtinC29Q/edit#heading=h.vbfw12u4ifu0
- Direct attention to DOI Discussion Google Page - Organized by Topic
- Keeping the conversation going - Consider Wiki Area for each topic - editable use case areas - for more people to look at. Put out request to DAACs to submit their use-cases for documents so others can see and get ideas and provide input. Google Docs could be setup easier then transfer to Wiki area for safe-keeping.
- Track where we are in these discussion topics
- Move mature topics to ESO review
- Val: Consider Earthdata Forum mechanism to capture discussions
- Actions from last meeting
- Send Wiki link and Database access instructions to callers
- https://wiki.earthdata.nasa.gov/display/DOIsforEOSDIS/EOSDIS+DOIs+Status+and+Listing
- Lalit to provide database access instructions
- Send policy document and Use case document to attendees
- Nate will post link to these documents in meeting notes
- Steve has an additional Use-Case for us
- Create a NASA distribution list of users and interested parties - Done (internal section)
- Setup Google Drive for DOI discussion topics - Done
- Next Steps Topic: DOIs in CMR
- DOIs presently referenced in CMR
- UMM-C
- Populating DOIs in CMR
- Using MMT
- DOI is NOT a required field - not all products are used in research (eg. L0 data, quick/first look)
- Using CMR API interfacing with DAACs script
- Alicia: Explanation of absent DOI field did NOT work - Val will check
- Q: Will this DOI field make the product searchable by DOI?
A: Yes - Tested live - Returns proper result
Still some natural language issues in the search (using auto-populating if DOI field typed) - Status of DOIs on legacy datasets vs new datasets
- Most DAACs have assigned DOIs to all of their active datasets.
Why put DOIs on legacy (retired) datasets if papers already written?
A: Depends on what “legacy” means - no longer available or retired datasets should not have DOIs.
- Most DAACs have assigned DOIs to all of their active datasets.
- Related DOI-CMR Topics for future discussion
- DOIs for algorithms (ATBDs) and software
- UMM-S - DOIs for services
- UMM-Tools - DOIs for tools
- UMM-V - DOIs for Disaster Events (WorldView and GIBS)
- Future Topics to Add to the DOI Discussion Google Doc
- Topic
- Should we be registering DOIs at a Mission level before data is publicly available (i.e. airborne missions)
- Who’s interested
- Related documents and links to reference
- Next Discussion Topic:
- Next Tentative Telecon Date: May/June