Page History
...
Reviewer | Feedback | Response | Status |
---|---|---|---|
Daniel Ziskin (ziskin@ucar.edu) | My main feeling was that it wasn't clear how to begin. I stumbled along without confidence in the beginning. I would have liked to see some simple instructions like: 1) Download this Excel spreadsheet (please notice that there are multiple sheets) 2) Review the proposed changes 3) Submit this questionnaire
Many times I got confused about Level 1 parameters or Level 2 or what. When I returned to the spreadsheet it made sense but the phrasing of the questions when I first read was baffling. I had to flip back and forth too many times for the question to make sense. I would suggest adding some kind of pictorial representation of the current and proposed changes on the questionnaire itself. When I was filling out the questionnaire the question would be something like "Do you approve of the proposed change of moving Variable Level 2 Convective Surface Wind to Variable Level 3?" I just remember feeling very confused trying to keep all the Levels straight in my head and going back-and-forth between the form and the spreadsheet. The Level numbers just didn't help me. |
| In WorkDone |
John Scialdone (jscialdo@ciesin.columbia.edu) | Q4: Recommends Humidity Indicators at Variable Level 1 instead of Humidity Expressions Q5: Recommends to split Convergence/Divergence into separate Variable Level 2 Words (e.g. Convergence, Divergence) Q6: Capitalize p in profile in the Velocity Azimuth Display Vertical Wind profile (e.g. Velocity Azimuth Display Vertical Wind Profile) Recommends to split |
| In WorkDone |
Deborah Smith (dks0017@uah.edu) |
|
| In WorkDone |
. |